South Africa: Khampepe Stays as Head of TRC Probe Commission After Zuma, Mbeki Recusal Bid Fails

Retired Justice Sisi Khampepe will continue chairing the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into alleged political interference in Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) cases.

The Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg dismissed a legal challenge on Monday from former presidents Jacob Zuma and Thabo Mbeki seeking her recusal. President Cyril Ramaphosa appointed Khampepe to lead the commission in May 2025.

The bid stemmed from whistleblower claims that Khampepe colluded with evidence leader Semenya. Allegations included her advising him during his own recusal application last year, providing “tips” to his counsel Advocate Vas Soni SC, and “coaching” him on case strategy.

Among the grounds sought for Justice Khampepe’s recusal were that she worked for the TRC’s amnesty committee and as Deputy National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP) before being appointed to the bench. Zuma sought a declaration from the high court that Justice Khampepe’s dismissal of the recusal application was unconstitutional and invalid, as well as review and set aside the decision.

Alternatively, Zuma has asked the court to review and set aside Justice Khampepe’s decision on the basis of the principle of legality. Mbeki has asked the high court to order that Ramaphosa terminate his appointment of Justice Khampepe and declare all the decisions the commission has taken so far under her null and void.